Why Having Kids is Foolish

I just read an article entitled “Why Having Kids is Foolish”.

The first paragraph:

All parents know that having kids is a blessing — except when it’s a nightmare of screaming fits, diapers, runny noses, wars over bedtimes and homework and clothes. To say nothing of bills too numerous to list. Some economists have argued that having kids is an economically silly investment; after all, it’s cheaper to hire end-of-life care than to raise a child. Now comes new research showing that having kids is not only financially foolish but that kids literally make parents delusional.

The article goes on argue that parents delude themselves into idealizing the emotional rewards of parenthood to rationalize the financial cost.  It explains how parents tend to be angrier, more depressed and more stressed out than non-parents.

And I’m thinking, lovers are that way too.  Love anyone deeply and there will be regular episodes of anger, depression and stress.  Love complicates things.  I guess by the logic of this article it could also be argued that love of any kind is a delusion (except self-love).

My children are still very young, but it is not difficult to see how having kids requires significant sacrifice and self-denial.  My daughter was colicky and cried almost non-stop during her second month.  It was stressful: my wife and I argued more during that month than the rest of our seven years of marriage combined.

According to the article, the stress isn’t worth it.  We only tell ourselves that it is – it’s nature’s trick to keep us propagating our genes.  If we sane and clear-headed, we would realize that kids cramp our style.

Or is it love that cramps our style?  As a pastor, I’ve watched plenty of young people who I’ve invested in make foolish, self-destructive decisions. Watching students I love hurt themselves and those around them can make me angry and depressed like nothing else.

I’m sure there are any number of occupations that would allow me to avoid this kind of personal investment and heartbreak.

But I don’t want them.

Why? Because the very act of self-giving enlarges the soul in a way that can’t be quantified in a psychological study.

I’m not saying that a person can’t be fully alive without having kids.  But if you avoid the things that cost you blood, sweat and tears, if you avoid anyone who could break your heart?  Your life will be empty.

The bottom line: if your goal is to live a comfortable life with little risk, few inconveniences and maximum self-gratification, then yes, having children is foolish.

So is getting married. And having deep friendships. And following Jesus. And serving the poor.  And fighting against injustice.

All of these things will profoundly complicate and inconvenience your life.

But luckily, you won’t pass on your genes.

Because the world needs people who know that life isn’t about all about them.

Advertisements

8 thoughts on “Why Having Kids is Foolish

  1. I was led to this article (original one about not having kids) by a colleague who posted a link to it on Facebook – she just had to repost for all her “non-breeding friends”. It took much restraint for me not to post something negative to her link. What I don’t understand is why people have to rub people on the face with their belief system. How ignorant it is to not understand that there is no black & white here: it’s a highly personal decision that is right for some & wrong for others. Why do these “childfree by choice people” have to keep treating those who have children like brainwashed idiots? In response to the emotional & financial costs to have children, I have one response – DUH! This is the best you can come up with? And who hasn’t learned by now that the most rewarding things in life rarely come easy? Parenting is a choice. For me it’s the right thing to do. For others it’s not the right thing to do. To me, as a psychologist and counselor, people who spend time tearing down others to prove they are right are generally the most unhappy. There is not one answer to this. Some people are built for parenting & some aren’t. Just thank God (or Buddha or the Goddess more likely) that your mom didn’t have the same view or you wouldn’t have your body & brain that her 23 chromosomes & womb allowed you to have. I’m with you – we don’t need those genes in our genepool! So go travel, love your dog & job but leave those who have children by choice (not some mindless thing for all of us) alone!

  2. A beautiful response to an incredibly short-sighted article.

    TIME should have published this blog post instead of that terrible article.

    God bless you!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s